|
British Medical Bulletin - current issue
|
British Medical Bulletin - RSS feed of current issue
|
-
Cell-based therapies for lung disease
Introduction or background
The adult lung is a complex organ whose large surface area interfaces extensively with both the environment and circulatory system. Yet, in spite of the high potential for exposure to environmental or systemic harm, epithelial cell turnover in adult lung is comparatively slow. Moreover, loss of lung function with advancing age is becoming an increasingly costly healthcare problem. Cell-based therapies stimulating endogenous stem/progenitor cells or supplying exogenous ones have therefore become a prime translational goal. Alternatively when lung repair becomes impossible, replacement with tissue-engineered lung is an attractive emerging alternative using a decellularized matrix or bioengineered scaffold.
Sources of data
Endogenous and exogenous stem cells for lung therapy are being characterized by defining developmental lineages, surface marker expression, functions within the lung and responses to injury and disease. Seeding decellularized lung tissue or bioengineered matrices with various stem and progenitor cells is an approach that has already been used to replace bronchus and trachea in human patients and awaits further development for whole lung tissue.
Areas of agreement
Cellular therapies have clear potential for respiratory disease. However, given the surface size and complexity of lung structure, the probability of a single cellular population sufficing to regenerate the entire organ, as in the bone marrow, remains low. Hence, lung regenerative medicine is currently focused around three aims: (i) to identify and stimulate resident cell populations that respond to injury or disease, (ii) to transplant exogenous cells which can ameliorate disease and (iii) to repopulate decellularized or bioengineered lung matrix creating a new implantable organ.
Areas of controversy
Lack of consensus on specific lineage markers for lung stem and progenitor cells in development and disease constrains transferability of research between laboratories and sources of cellular therapy. Furthermore, effectiveness of individual cellular therapies to correct gas exchange and provide other critical lung functions remains unproven. Finally, feasibility of autologous whole organ replacement has not been confirmed as a durable therapy.
Growing points
Cellular therapies for lung regeneration would be enhanced by better lineage tracing within the lung, the ability to direct differentiation of exogenous stem or progenitor cells, and the development of functional assays for cellular viability and regenerative properties. Whether endogenous or exogeneous cells will ultimately play a greater therapeutic role remains to be seen. Reducing the need for lung replacement via endogenous cell-mediated repair is a key goal. Thereafter, improving the potential of donor lungs in transplant recipients is a further area where cell-based therapies may be beneficial. Ultimately, lung replacement with autologous tissue-engineered lungs is another goal for cell-based therapy.
Areas timely for developing research
Defining ‘lung stem or progenitor cell’ populations in both animal models and human tissue may help. Additionally, standardizing assays for assessing the potential of endogenous or exogenous cells within the lung is important. Understanding cell–matrix interactions in real time and with biomechanical insight will be central for lung engineering.
Cautionary note
Communicating the real potential for cell-based lung therapy needs to remain realistic, given the keen expectations of patients with end-stage lung disease.
-
The neurobiology of depression
Introduction or background
Depressive disorder is a long term, relapsing condition associated with high levels of disability and mortality. It has a neurobiological basis and is associated with functional and structural brain abnormalities.
Sources of data
The data discussed have been obtained mainly from meta-analyses, randomized controlled clinical trials and key review papers as well as animal studies.
Areas of agreement
Genetic vulnerability and stress are key factors in its aetiopathogenesis. Dysregulation of the hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis reduces hippocampal volumes and prefrontal cortex (PFC) activity in depressed patients and disrupts homeostasis within the neurocircuit of depression. Antidepressant drugs increase brain-derived neurotrophin, restoring neuronal growth and activity and modulate interactions between the neurocircuit anatomical structures.
Areas of controversy
It remains to be confirmed whether structural changes in the brain are purely abnormalities in neuroplasticity and are fully reversible, whether they predate depression and whether they increase in the long term.
Growing points
Investigation of the molecular mechanisms mediating gene and environment interaction is a growing and potentially fruitful area of research in the neurobiology of depression. Further elucidation of the neuroanatomical and physiological connections between the limbic structures and PFC may help identify key areas to target in treatment. The role of the dysregulation of the HPA axis and identifiable stressors in the recent or remote past which are not always present in depression need further study.
Areas timely for developing research
Prospective studies examining the interaction between changes in brain function and structure in relation to stress and identified relevant genes and how these may be influenced by antidepressant drug treatment and the long-term course of depression would help clarify their role in the pathophysiology of this disorder.
-
Neurological disorders and the potential role for stem cells as a therapy
Introduction
Neurological disorders are routinely characterized by loss of cells in response to an injury or a progressive insult. Stem cells could therefore be useful to treat these disorders.
Sources of data
Pubmed searches of recent literature.
Areas of agreement
Stem cells exhibit proliferative capacity making them ideally suited for replacing dying cells. However, instead of cell replacement therapy stem cell transplants frequently appear to work via neurotrophic factor release, immunomodulation and upregulation of endogenous stem cells.
Areas of controversy and areas timely for developing research
Many questions remain with respect to the use of stem cells as a therapy, the answers to which will vary depending on the disorder to be treated and mode of action. Whereas the potential tumorigenic capability of stem cells is a concern, most studies do not support this notion. Further determination of the optimal cell type, and whether to perform allogeneic or autologous transplants warrant investigation before the full potential of stem cells can be realized. In addition, the use of stem cells to develop disease models should not be overlooked.
-
Overview of anesthetic considerations for Cesarean delivery
Introduction
Physiologic changes of pregnancy uniquely influence anesthesia for Cesarean delivery. Included is a review of current obstetrical anesthesia considerations for Cesarean delivery and recent changes improving maternal care and outcome.
Sources of data
A literature review was conducted using Pubmed and the Cochrane database.
Areas of agreement and controversy
Increased use of neuraxial techniques instead of general anesthesia for Cesarean delivery has improved maternal safety. Recent changes in the prevention of gastric aspiration, hypotension from neuraxial techniques, venous thrombosis and a team approach have improved maternal care. Elective Cesarean deliveries and management of urgent deliveries are areas of discussion.
Areas timely for developing research
Obstetric anesthesia advances have improved maternal outcomes. Current areas of needed obstetric anesthesia research include improved obese patient care, the impact of anticoagulation on neuraxial techniques in pregnancy, long-term neurocognitive effects of neonatal exposure to anesthesia and postoperative pain management.
-
Is the QALY blind, deaf and dumb to equity? NICE's considerations over equity
Introduction/background
The quality-adjusted life year (QALY) is the preferred measure of health outcome used to inform decisions over the use of health care interventions in the UK NHS. This measure considers the overall impact of alternative interventions on both the quantity and quality of life.
Sources of data
Review of the relevant literature.
Areas of agreement
The QALY assumes that health improvement is equally valued between individuals.
Areas of controversy
Some can perceive as equitable, that is fair, the assumption that health improvement is equally valued between individuals in the QALY. However, others may believe that this assumption leaves no space for alternative views over equity to be explicitly considered in societal decision making.
Growing points
The role of equity in decision making in the UK has been subject of intense debate, and controversy, and to-date there is no consensus on whether, or how, should NICE should change their general process.
Areas timely for developing research
Further examination of the issues needs to be debated and researched.
|